Conversely, defenders of the book, particularly within certain traditional pesantren (Islamic boarding schools), argue that condemning the entire work is a mistake. Their key points include:
In Manba’ Ushul Al-Hikmah , on page 323, Imam al-Buni details his sanad for the " Talqin Syahadat " (the instruction of the testimony of faith). This chain connects him directly to the Prophet through a lineage of spiritual masters, including: The author → Syeikh Abi Abdillah Muhammad... → ... → Imam Musa al-Kazhim → Imam Ja’far Shadiq → Imam Muhammad al-Baqir → Imam Zainal ‘Abidin → Sayyidina Al Husain → Sayyidina Ali bin Abi Thalib → . manba ushul al hikmah pdf
A commentary on the ancient "Oath of Berhatiah" (invocations). Manba' Usul al-Hikmah منبع أصول الحكمة - Jarir
Manba' Usul al-Hikmah منبع أصول الحكمة - Jarir Bookstore defenders of the book
It is arguably more structured and "practical" than the Shams al-Ma'arif , making it a manual rather than just a collection of lore.
It represents a significant part of folk-Islamic tradition that has influenced spiritual practices from North Africa to Southeast Asia for centuries. Weaknesses & Controversies
Instructions on constructing magic squares ( Awfaq ) and talismans for protection, healing, or influence.